“Can you teach me how to belt like Demi Lovato?”
Well, that depends. What is your natural voice type? Do you have a similar voice type to Demi’s? If yes, absolutely! If your voice type is drastically different, I can teach you how to belt, but your belt will not be comparable to hers.
When talking about voice types, there are broad categories centered around range (soprano, mezzo-soprano, contralto, tenor, baritone, bass), and then there are sub-categories with more subtle differences. I won’t get into the details of voice classifications in this article. Unless you’re singing opera, the difference between a coloratura, lyric, soubrette, spinto and dramatic soprano is irrelevant. But at the very least, you should know this: Voices differ in natural capacities for range, volume, and flexibility. Sade at her loudest will never be as loud as Whitney Houston at her loudest. Jhene Aiko’s belt won’t sound like Idina Menzel’s belt. Ever. Not even with voice lessons every day from now until 2035. There’s nothing wrong with that. Naturally louder voices aren’t necessarily better or worse than naturally softer voices, they’re just different.
Have you ever seen the musical Dreamgirls? That’s a great example of a production that showcases different voice types. (The 1981 Broadway show does a better job of illustrating this point than the movie adaptation) Dreamgirls tells the story of a 60s girl group, reminiscent of the Supremes.
The members of the group are:
Deena, the light-voiced head-dominant singer (Think Diana Ross instead of Beyoncé)
Effie, the gospel style belter
and Lorell, the soprano who sings in a bright mix (Patti LaBelle type)
The differences in voice type are significant because Deena and Effie’s vocal abilities are pitted against each other in the story. When filtered through a “louder is better” lens, it feels like an injustice when Deena is chosen to sing lead over the powerhouse belter, Effie.
Every time I’ve auditioned for productions of Dreamgirls, I’ve been cast as Deena. I could never, ever play Effie and that’s okay. I know my lane and I stay in it. I’m a light lyric soprano (my voice is on the higher, lighter, softer side), so I learn Deena type repertoire and audition for Deena type roles. Even when I sing R&B/pop music, I’ve started to lean towards covering lighter-voiced singers.
Trying to force your voice outside of its “happy place” can lead to problems. Softer-voiced singers often blow their voices out trying to sing huge songs with huge instrumentation. Singers with naturally louder voices often create vocal tension when trying to hold back their volume to blend with softer voices. Neither is necessary. Figure out what you do well and play to your strengths!
As talented as they are, if Jennifer Holiday or Jennifer Hudson (who both played Effie) took a quiet, contemplative Sade song and belted it out with gospel growls and squalls, it would have the same jarring effect of Miss Lake Dardenelle's famous 2010 performance of “And I Am Telling You (I’m Not Going)”. To put it nicely, neither is stylistically appropriate.
(Note: If you want to put a unique spin on a song that's outside of your voice type, you can absolutely do that! However, I would highly recommend changing the instrumentation/production/arrangement to match your new interpretation of the song. That way, it sounds intentional and not like a mistake.)
In both musical theater and contemporary commercial music, there’s an audience for every type of singer. Whether you’re a belter like Demi or Aretha, a crooner like Nat King Cole, or your voice is super soft, like Billie Eilish, there’s an audience for all of it. There’s no need to try to contort your voice into something it’s not. Embrace your natural gifts and lean into them.
A word of caution, regardless of where you lie on the volume spectrum, you won’t be able to please everyone. There are people who “wish Fantasia would stop all that screaming” and there are others who think that “Diana Ross’ voice isn’t strong enough”. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but you are also entitled to ignore all outside opinions from the peanut gallery and thrive exactly as you are.
This is not to say that you can't strengthen your voice and increase your volume. You absolutely can, and should! It’s something that I work with all of my students on. However, as you set your vocal goals, aim to be the best possible version of YOU, not someone else. As you choose your repertoire, be sure to choose songs that present your voice in the most flattering light. It takes the struggle out of the equation and leaves room for you to have fun and be expressive. That's really the point, right?